Where to Find the Best Homemade Pies – A Local’s Guide

Pies. Glorious, golden, flaky, and packed with flavour. There's something special about biting into a homemade pie, filled with love and tradition. Whether sweet or savoury, they bring comfort, nostalgia, and downright happiness. If you're on the hunt for the best homemade pies in the Strathalbyn and Milang regions of South Australia, you’re in for a treat – quite literally.

A Bite of Tradition

Local bakeries in this area have been perfecting their craft for decades. Many have recipes passed down through generations, ensuring every bite delivers that unmistakable homemade goodness. You won’t find mass-produced, generic flavours here. Instead, expect rich, buttery pastry that crumbles just right and fillings that ooze with real ingredients.

Flaky, But Never a Letdown

What makes a pie truly unforgettable? The pastry. It needs to have the perfect balance of crispness and buttery goodness while still letting the filling shine. Some places swear by using only local butter, while others have secret techniques that have been guarded for years. One bite, and you'll know you're in the presence of something special.

The Savoury Showstoppers

For those who love their pies on the savoury side, the region's classic meat pies speak for themselves. Slow-cooked chunks of beef in a rich, thick gravy wrapped in a golden crust? Yes, please. For something different, think lamb and rosemary, creamy chicken and leek, or the ultimate steak and mushroom.

And let's not forget the vegetarian stars. A perfectly seasoned spinach and ricotta pie or a hearty roasted vegetable and lentil version can hold their own against any meat-filled counterpart.

Sweet Pies That Steal the Spotlight

Nothing says comfort like a freshly baked apple pie, with cinnamon-spiced apples bubbling beneath a hand-crimped crust. Classic flavours like blueberry and peach never disappoint, but some bakeries go the extra mile with indulgent creations such as salted caramel pecan or rich chocolate ganache.

And if you ever come across a homemade jam tart or a traditional lemon meringue pie, just do yourself a favour and order a slice—or the whole thing.

Where the Pie Magic Happens

Here are some local bakeries renowned for their homemade pies:

Strath Corner Bakery

Location: Dawson St, Strathalbyn SA 5255

A well-established bakery known for its fresh pies, pasties, sausage rolls, cakes, and sandwiches, along with country-style breakfasts.

Milang Bakery

Location: 29 Luard St, Milang SA 5256

A local favourite offering freshly baked bread, rolls, cakes, pastries, hot pies, pasties, and sausage rolls. A must stop when you are heading to Milang

Peska’s Bakery

Location: Dawson Stt, Strathalbyn, SA

A family-owned bakery specialising in fresh breads, pies, and pasties, bringing homemade tradition to the local community.

Freshly Baked Memories

Nothing beats the taste of a pie made with care, from a place that values tradition and flavour. Whether you're craving a classic beef pie or a sweet apple delight, this region has something to satisfy your cravings.

So next time you're passing through Strathalbyn or Milang, stop in at one of these bakeries and grab a pie. Who knows? You might just find a new favourite.

Happy pie hunting! Cheers, Candeece

I blog about Strathalbyn and the surrounding area and my mission is to highlight all the small businesses, organisations and events that make our region great. Please reach out if you would like to be involved with guest blogging.

Stay Connected

✅ Follow us on social media: Our Strathalbyn on Facebook